Paul Theisen
Executive Stewardship
Altitude Index
Coming 2027

Outmaneuvering Goliath

How Mid-Market CEOs Compete with Giants and Win

The problem is not that technology is moving too fast. It is that leadership models have not moved at all. This is the case that mid-market companies hold structural advantages the giants cannot buy, and the instruction manual for pairing those advantages with judgment that used to be out of reach.

Pre-order from your favorite retailer
Join the launch list
The Cover · The Argument

The smallest piece on the board, standing over the king.

The pawn on the cover does not win by being bigger. It wins on position and discipline. That is the argument of the book: mid-market companies hold structural advantages the giants cannot buy, and the leaders who use them well outmaneuver companies many times their size.

Join the launch list
What Is Inside

Four parts, one argument.

From the hidden problem, through the misdiagnosis, into the disciplines battle-tested C-level leaders actually run, and out to a new model for getting wisdom into a leadership layer that cannot afford it full-time.

Part I

The Hidden Problem

Why capable companies still lose ground. The leadership talent gap, and what AI is doing to C-suite decision-making.

Part II

The Misdiagnosis

Why smart leaders keep making bad bets. One C-suite hat at a time, the opportunity cost of ineffective management, and the Pyramid of Chaos.

Part III

Thinking Like Battle-Tested Leaders

Five Nouns and Four Verbs. Designing operations around the business value proposition. IT black hole or IT investment portfolio. True costs and ROI. The chasm between implementation and adoption.

Part IV

The New Model

Wisdom at the leadership level. Have the courage to lead. The value of a well-placed assessment. Architecting the C-suite. Conclusion: the hidden advantage.

The Frameworks

The operating system underneath the book.

Six models, each built from a specific seat in a specific kind of company.

Paul credits the deeper bones of this work to Deming, to ITIL, and to Carnegie Mellon’s capability maturity research. As he puts it, these fundamentals have been winning for decades.

01

The Pilot Serving Drinks

Role clarity at altitude

Read the framework
02

The Pyramid of Chaos

Four stages of decision culture

Read the framework
03

Five Nouns and Four Verbs

The operating model in plain language

Read the framework
04

Three Ways to Win

Designing operations around the value proposition

Read the framework
05

The IT Investment Portfolio

Or the black hole, and you are running one of them

Read the framework
06

The Amplifier and the Controller

What AI actually changes

Read the framework
Framework 01

The Pilot Serving Drinks

Role clarity at altitude

The most expensive person in the company is usually the least qualified to manage technology.

A low-budget airline pilot gets one hundred and thirty passengers to thirty-five thousand feet, flips on autopilot, then leaves the cockpit to serve drinks. Who is watching the instruments? A CEO owns requirements. A technology leader translates those requirements into options and carries accountability for execution. When both roles collapse into one overloaded person, the company is flying the plane and serving drinks at the same time.

  • At thirty-five thousand feet, someone has to stay in the cockpit
  • A conductor who steps down to play the violin improves one section and costs the whole orchestra its coordination
  • The promotion trap: orchestration is not a bigger version of execution
  • Technology enables. Management directs.
Framework 02

The Pyramid of Chaos

Four stages of decision culture

Shared accountability is plausible deniability.”

Built from a decade in the CIO chair watching each stage fail in its own particular way. Stage one is the free-for-all, where influence decides. Stage two is the committee, which becomes theater because its members have limited time, limited authority, and shared accountability. Stage three is the program office: dedicated hands, still no single accountable will. Stage four is one accountable executive who owns priorities, budget, and outcomes.

  • An organization run well is a benevolent dictatorship, with the emphasis on benevolent
  • Air cover means that if the thing goes south, one person loses a job over it
  • Accountability nobody enforces is just a longer word for hoping
  • A fractional executive can hold the top of the pyramid part-time, because the seat is real
Framework 03

Five Nouns and Four Verbs

The operating model in plain language

If it’s planned, it must be built. If it’s built, it must be supported. If it’s supported, it must be improved.

Five nouns laid flat with no senior partner: strategy, budget, people, process, technology. On a job site, technology is the machine, people are the skill to operate it, budget is the fuel, process is the rules of where to dig, and strategy is where we are digging and why. Four verbs move them: plan, build, support, monitor. Improvement follows monitoring.

  • Planning is the most underfunded verb. Plans are nothing, planning is everything.
  • Support consumes fifty to sixty percent of a technology budget, keeping promises already made
  • Sufficient to purpose: engineer to exactly the standard the business requires, no further
  • The red Solo cup looking for a college party is a solution hunting for a budget. Requirements come first.
  • Paul credits the bones to Deming, ITIL, and Carnegie Mellon. These fundamentals have been winning for decades.
Framework 04

Three Ways to Win

Designing operations around the value proposition

Technology should reinforce what makes you different, not erase it.

The triangle belongs to Michael Treacy and Fred Wiersema: operational excellence, product leadership, customer intimacy. Paul teaches it with hamburgers. McDonald’s runs sameness and mass optimization. Wendy’s runs product leadership and asks where the beef is. Burger King runs customer intimacy, a buffet with a fence around it. Pick one and mean it.

  • Roughly eighty percent of competency into the chosen discipline, the other two held at baseline
  • The middle of the triangle is mediocrity
  • Size shapes which game is available to you
  • The bullseye ideal client profile, and saying no to revenue outside it
  • Framework credited to Treacy and Wiersema. The application is Paul's.
Framework 05

The IT Investment Portfolio

Or the black hole, and you are running one of them

A portfolio of IT projects is like managing a mutual fund: reallocate resources from losers and allocate more resources to winners.

The technology leader as chief investment officer. The blended return of the whole portfolio has to clear the hurdle rate, which means the portfolio presupposes losers. The alternative is the black hole: management that expects everything and participates in nothing, ambiguity and jargon as cover, survival by appearances, and the always-late manager whose yes is a no in disguise.

  • Put losers on a clock. A ninety-day pause with a hard expiration.
  • Kill or commit, with the criteria set before the project starts
  • One office to answer to: a program office paired with a single accountable executive sponsor
  • Clean accountability removes the fall-guy dynamic that keeps dead projects alive
  • Help me collect my money beats help me spend my money, almost every time
Framework 06

The Amplifier and the Controller

What AI actually changes

AI doesn’t replace judgment. It exposes the lack of it.

Shovel to backhoe to bucket-wheel excavator. The combine harvester. The stadium microphone. AI is logical leverage at continuous scale, and the organization starts to remember itself. The real shift is capacity, not capability. And because what was knowable at decision time becomes visible, leaders end up altogether without excuse.

  • The Amplifier Effect: AI is a mirror that reveals and accelerates what is already there
  • Garbage in becomes garbage out at scale
  • Bring order to what exists before adding power
  • AI absorbs the preparatory layer, so judgment becomes the visible differentiator and busyness stops passing for leadership
  • AI is the great amplifier. Human intelligence is the controller.
Endorsements

What readers are saying

“In his latest project, Outmaneuvering Goliath, Paul Theisen shows us his authentic approach to helping others. Using stories and language that are quick to grasp, Paul’s real passion for serving others shines through. The energy he shares through his writing and insight is a lasting way to continue to share his leadership approach.”
Scott DelaneyFormer VP & GM Tech Data Lifecycle Services; Managing Partner, Tiburon Cloud Partners
Scott Delaney
“The business landscape has fundamentally shifted. Private equity consolidation, artificial intelligence disruption, volatile capital markets, and relentless supply chain pressures have created an environment where mid-sized companies face an existential crossroads: adapt or be absorbed. Paul’s book is the strategic playbook that middle market leaders have been desperately waiting for. Rather than viewing their size as a liability, Paul masterfully reframes it as a competitive superpower, unlocking the agility, speed, and market intelligence that neither startups nor enterprise giants can replicate. This is not theory. This is a battle-tested roadmap for thriving in one of the most challenging business climates in modern history. Every middle market executive needs to consider these ideas as a way to succeed going forward.”
David MylesFormer PE Operating Partner, Bestige Holdings and 3x CEO; Board Director; Vistage Chair
David Myles
“I had the opportunity to work closely with Paul and saw firsthand his ability to think strategically, make difficult decisions, and still drive the tactics necessary to get results. Outmaneuvering Goliath reflects the same qualities I saw in Paul as an executive: clarity of thought, sound judgment, persistence, and a practical understanding of how organizations really operate. It is a valuable book for mid-market leaders who understand that you don’t need to be the biggest company to be the better competitor.”
Mike KemperFormer President & CEO, NPL Construction Company; Consultant and Board Director
Mike Kemper
“Outmaneuvering Goliath contains fresh insights and encouraging inspiration for middle market CEOs! Paul provides convincing arguments and practical strategies to outperform larger competitors with technology reaching its full potential to catalyze growth.” Paul’s book is the strategic playbook that middle market leaders have been desperately waiting for. Rather than viewing their size as a liability, Paul masterfully reframes it as a competitive superpower, unlocking the agility, speed, and market intelligence that neither startups nor enterprise giants can replicate. This is not theory. This is a battle-tested roadmap for thriving in one of the most challenging business climates in modern history. Every middle market executive needs to consider these ideas as a way to succeed going forward.”
Mike StanleyChair, C12 Greater Phoenix; Board Director
Mike Stanley
“Paul Theisen clearly articulates a challenge many growing companies face but struggle to define: organizational complexity outpacing leadership capacity. As a COO who successfully integrated a fractional CIO into our business, I have seen firsthand many of the advantages described in this book. Outmaneuvering Goliath offers practical insights for leaders looking to scale smarter, make better decisions, and unlock the full potential of their organizations.”Paul’s book is the strategic playbook that middle market leaders have been desperately waiting for. Rather than viewing their size as a liability, Paul masterfully reframes it as a competitive superpower, unlocking the agility, speed, and market intelligence that neither startups nor enterprise giants can replicate. This is not theory. This is a battle-tested roadmap for thriving in one of the most challenging business climates in modern history. Every middle market executive needs to consider these ideas as a way to succeed going forward.”
Alfonso TrujilloChief Operating Officer, MMI Industrial & Steel
Alfonso Trujillo
“There’s an adage that 'the strong beat the weak, and the smart beat the strong.' Paul provides relatable stories on how mid-market companies can leverage leadership and technology to outmaneuver their goliath competition. This book is a must-read for anyone who wants to understand how to combine the nimbleness of a mid-market company with the leadership talent of a goliath.” This is not theory. This is a battle-tested roadmap for thriving in one of the most challenging business climates in modern history. Every middle market executive needs to consider these ideas as a way to succeed going forward.”
Eric WalterChief Financial Officer and PE Operating Partner, DMC Global
Eric Walter
“A clear perspective on challenges growing companies face but few recognize. Calling out the gap between organizational complexity and leadership capacity is a bedrock challenge faced by management in every organization. Paul makes a compelling case that technology and AI are not substitutes for judgment; rather, they amplify the discipline, clarity, and accountability already present in an organization. His practical framework for aligning leadership, talent, and technology gives middle-market leaders a way to move with greater confidence, agility, and intention. Most importantly, the book reminds me that the real competitive advantage is not having more resources, but knowing how to apply the right judgment at the right time.”
Chad FayPresident, High Country France
Chad Fay
Launch List

One email when pre-orders open.

Paul will email once, when pre-orders open. Nothing else.